With the reelection of Donald Trump as President of the United States, many are grappling with an uneasy question: Is American democracy nearing its breaking point? Some are even pondering the unthinkable – will America soon join the ranks of other failed democracies? Trump, undoubtedly one of the most flawed and corrupt individuals ever to occupy the nation’s highest office, has demonstrated a willingness to disregard established norms and laws. This raises fears that in his next administration, Trump will push the boundaries of executive power so much as to turn our country, at the very least, into something less than a full democracy.  

Trump’s history of surrounding himself with loyalists, often at the expense of competence or accountability, suggests that his second term could feature a government stacked with toadies willing to carry out his orders, lawful or not. That quaint American concept of checks and balances may soon be relevant only in the context of bank statements. The potential for executive overreach seems almost inevitable, particularly if key institutions, such as Congress or the judiciary, fail to stop his worst impulses.

The rule of law, which has already taken some big hits, could be further eroded under another four years of Trump. Critics have pointed to the actions of the Supreme Court, which, under its current conservative majority, has issued controversial rulings that many view as politically motivated or dismissive of precedent. The perception of a judiciary compromised by partisan hacks erodes public trust and weakens one of democracy’s crucial guardrails.

The stakes could not be higher. A second Trump term will no doubt test the resilience of American democracy like never before. Many fear that Trump’s disregard for institutional norms, coupled with a fragmented political landscape and widespread misinformation, could create conditions ripe for “democratic” authoritarianism, much as is the case in Hungary. 

So, will American democracy survive? The answer, at this point, feels like a coin toss. On one side, the nation still possesses strong institutions, a free press, and an engaged populace—resources that have historically bolstered democracy in times of crisis. On the other side, growing polarization, declining trust in government, a corrupt Supreme Court, flourishing right wing disinformation outlets, and the potential for unchecked executive power represent existential threats.

America stands at a crossroads, with uncertainty looming over what this nation might look like after another four years of Donald Trump – if he even makes it to the end of his term! My hope is that Trump and his MAGA allies will overreach so drastically that even his most diehard supporters will push back, rallying to preserve what we still love to call “The Great American Experiment.”

Related